Shopify to Magento: Is It Worth the Switch in 2025?

As your online business grows, so do your platform needs.

While Shopify is a great starting point for many eCommerce businesses due to its ease of use and all-in-one hosting, some store owners begin to feel its limitations in flexibility, customization, and control — especially as they scale.

That’s where Magento (also known as Adobe Commerce) comes into the picture.

So, in 2025, is it worth switching from Shopify to Magento?

In this article, we’ll explore:

• Key differences between Shopify and Magento

• Pros and cons of each

• When it makes sense to migrate Shopify to Magento

• And how to make the switch without losing your store data using Cart2Cart, the trusted Shopify to Magento migration tool

Shopify vs Magento 2025: Quick Comparison

Why Consider Migrating from Shopify to Magento?

If you're a growing eCommerce business or enterprise brand, you may be hitting Shopify’s limits. Here’s why many merchants move from Shopify to Magento:

1. Full Platform Ownership & Code Access

Magento gives you 100% control over your store:

• Custom backend logic

• Full codebase modification

• No dependency on apps for custom functionality

2. Advanced Customization & Functionality

Magento allows:

• Custom pricing rules

• B2B functionality

• Complex shipping logic

• Multi-vendor features

• Multi-language and multi-currency support

You’re not bound to app limits or Shopify API constraints.

3. Native Multi-Store Management

Magento enables managing multiple storefronts (with different domains, catalogs, and currencies) from a single admin panel — a must-have for global brands.

Shopify doesn’t support true multistore functionality without multiple subscriptions.

4. Scalability for High-Volume Sales

Magento is ideal for:

• Large product catalogs (100k+ SKUs)

• Flash sales and heavy traffic spikes

• Custom ERP, CRM, and PIM integrations

Shopify, while reliable, requires expensive workarounds for high-volume features (e.g., Shopify Plus).

5. Enterprise-Level Security & Compliance

• Advanced security patches

• Role-based access

• PCI-compliant environments

• Custom hosting configurations

Perfect for businesses in regulated industries (finance, healthcare, etc.).

Reasons NOT to Switch to Magento

Magento is not for everyone. Before you migrate from Shopify to Magento, consider the following:

If you're a solo entrepreneur or small team without technical skills, Shopify may still be the better fit.

When It Makes Sense to Migrate Shopify to Magento

You should consider switching if:

• You’ve outgrown Shopify’s features or app limitations

• You need full control over performance, UX, and checkout logic

• You’re launching a multi-store or multi-language setup

• You’re looking for a B2B-ready platform

• Your dev team is familiar with PHP (Magento’s language)

How to Migrate from Shopify to Magento Without Losing Data

To safely transfer your Shopify store to Magento, use a trusted automated migration tool like Cart2Cart. Our detailed Shopify to Magento migration checklist can guide you through the process.

With Cart2Cart Shopify to Magento migration, you can migrate:

✅ Products, categories, SKUs, variants
✅ Customers and order history
✅ SEO URLs and meta data
✅ Reviews, taxes, currencies
✅ CMS pages, blog posts (optional)

Cart2Cart offers free demo migration so you can test before fully committing.

Step-by-Step Shopify to Magento Migration (via Cart2Cart)

1. Create a Cart2Cart account

2. Select Shopify as the source and Magento as the target

3. Connect both stores (via API/bridge)

4. Choose what to migrate

5. Run a free demo migration

6. Review results and launch the full migration

️ Your Shopify store remains active during migration. No downtime required.

Shopify to Magento Migration Costs

Magento Open Source is free, but development and customization require investment.

After the Migration: What’s Next?

Set Up Magento Admin

• Configure shipping, taxes, payments

• Customize email notifications

Choose a Theme

• Use a ready-made Magento 2 theme or build your own

• Ensure responsive, mobile-friendly design

Install Extensions

Magento Marketplace offers over 5,000 modules:

• Layered navigation

• Advanced search

• B2B modules

Rebuild SEO

• Set up 301 redirects from old Shopify URLs

• Re-submit sitemap to Google

• Install SEO modules like Mageplaza SEO or Amasty SEO Toolkit

Final Thoughts

Is switching from Shopify to Magento worth it in 2025?

For businesses ready to scale, Magento offers unmatched flexibility, power, and growth potential.

Ready to Make the Switch?

Don’t risk your data or SEO when migrating from Shopify to Magento. Use Cart2Cart to transfer your store safely and automatically.

Start Free Shopify to Magento Demo Migration
No coding. No data loss. No stress.

Monthly Update – December 2025

As we approach the end of 2025, the eCommerce landscape continues to emphasize advanced personalization and AI-driven insights. For Magento users, leveraging its robust architecture to implement sophisticated personalization engines is paramount. Consider integrating AI tools for predictive analytics to understand customer behavior, tailor product recommendations, and optimize marketing campaigns. This includes dynamic content delivery, personalized pricing strategies, and intelligent search functionalities that adapt to individual user preferences. Furthermore, with the growing importance of sustainability and ethical consumerism, brands migrating to or operating on Magento should highlight their commitment to these values. This can involve showcasing eco-friendly products, transparent supply chains, and offering sustainable shipping options. December is also a critical month for year-end inventory management and preparing for Q1 2026. Magento's powerful inventory management features, possibly augmented by advanced extensions, can help streamline stock control, reduce waste, and optimize fulfillment processes, ensuring you start the new year on a strong operational footing. Focusing on these areas will not only enhance customer experience but also drive long-term loyalty and growth.

For more details, explore our FAQ section or schedule a call with a migration expert.